Can My Sister be my Surrogate? The consideration of family as your surrogate.

by | Jan 22, 2024 | Gestational Surrogacy

When it comes to building a family through surrogacy, many intended parents consider involving a close family member, such as a sister, as their surrogate.

The idea of a trusted family member carrying your child can be appealing for various reasons, including a strong emotional connection and a sense of shared genetics. However, there are legal complexities associated with using a relative as a surrogate. In this blog post, we’ll delve into the legal reasons why a surrogate should not be related to the intended parents. 

  1. Avoiding Legal Complications

One of the primary reasons for not using a sister or any close family member as a surrogate is to avoid potential legal complications. Surrogacy laws vary from state to state, and in some places, they are quite ambiguous when it comes to familial surrogacy arrangements. This ambiguity can lead to issues regarding parental rights and custody after the child is born. 

In cases where the surrogate is related to the intended parents, courts may have difficulty distinguishing between the surrogate’s rights as a biological relative and her role as a gestational carrier. This can lead to disputes and lengthy legal battles over custody and parental rights, which can be emotionally draining and financially costly for all parties involved. 

  1. Clear Parental Rights

Using a non-related surrogate allows for a clear legal distinction between the intended parents and the surrogate. This clarity ensures that the intended parents have full parental rights from the moment the child is born, without any potential disputes or confusion. In contrast, when a sister serves as a surrogate, it can become challenging to establish these clear lines of parental rights. 

When the surrogate is not related to the intended parents, the legal process typically involves a pre-birth order or a post-birth adoption, depending on the state’s laws. These legal steps solidify the intended parents’ rights and provide a smooth transition into parenthood without the complications that can arise when surrogacy involves close family members. 

  1. Protection for the Surrogate

Choosing a non-related surrogate also offers protection for the surrogate herself. Surrogacy can be physically and emotionally demanding, and involving a family member as a surrogate may place undue stress on their relationship. Additionally, if complications arise during the pregnancy, it can be challenging for a sister-surrogate to make difficult medical decisions while also considering her familial ties. 

By using an unrelated surrogate, intended parents can ensure that their chosen surrogate is not burdened by complex emotional and familial dynamics and can focus on her own health and well-being throughout the pregnancy. 

  1. State-Specific Laws

It’s crucial to recognize that surrogacy laws are not uniform across all states. Some states explicitly prohibit familial surrogacy arrangements, while others have specific regulations in place to address these situations. It’s essential to consult with an experienced fertility attorney who is well-versed in the surrogacy laws of your state to understand the legal requirements and potential risks associated with using a sister as a surrogate. 

In states where familial surrogacy is allowed, there may still be additional legal hurdles and complexities that you must navigate. These can include mandatory counseling for all parties involved, extended waiting periods, and specific requirements for the surrogacy contract. 

While the idea of having a sister serve as a surrogate may be emotionally appealing, it’s essential to consider the legal ramifications and potential complications associated with familial surrogacy arrangements. To ensure a smooth and legally sound surrogacy journey, many intended parents choose to work with unrelated surrogates. 

By opting for a surrogate who is not a close family member, you can avoid legal complexities, establish clear parental rights, protect the surrogate’s well-being, and navigate state-specific surrogacy laws more easily. Ultimately, the decision to use a non-related surrogate is a practical choice that can help you achieve your dream of parenthood with fewer legal obstacles and less emotional stress. If you are considering surrogacy, it’s advisable to consult with a knowledgeable fertility attorney who can guide you through the legal aspects of the process and ensure that your rights and the surrogate’s rights are protected. 


Send Us a Message

7 + 5 =

*required fields